While Justice Scalia would have been grateful for the many warm tributes written about him over the last year, I wonder whether he would have noted, with his wry smile, one potentially awkward feature of them. Is not what we are doing uncomfortably close to one of his favorite targets in life: after-the-fact legislative history? Might he not have accused us of trying to introduce a friendly set of submissions in order to varnish this or that part of his life—to make it look like something it was not?