SLR Online

Response

The Dead Past

by  Alex Kozinski  

I must start out with a confession: When it comes to technology, I’m what you might call a troglodyte. I don’t own a Kindle or an iPad or an iPhone or a Blackberry. I don’t have an avatar or even voicemail. I don’t text. I don’t reject technology altogether: I do have a typewriter—an electric…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

animus-thick-thin_0

Essay

Animus Thick and Thin

The Broader Impact of the Ninth Circuit Decision in Perry v. Brown
by  Nan D. Hunter  

There is a concern among supporters of marriage equality, especially those in the legal academy, that the decision of the Ninth Circuit in Perry v. Brown was too good to be true or, perhaps, too clever to be sustainable. Judges Reinhardt and Hawkins crafted a decision that struck down Proposition 8 with reasoning that applies…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

cyber-security

Essay

In Search of Cyber Peace

A Response to the Cybersecurity Act of 2012
by  Scott J. Shackelford  

The Cybersecurity Act of 2012, which was recently introduced in the Senate Homeland Security and Governance Affairs Committee, is the latest legislative attempt to enhance the nation’s cybersecurity. If enacted, the bill would grant new powers to the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to oversee U.S. government cybersecurity, set “cybersecurity performance requirements” for firms operating…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

brownstones

Essay

Physical and Regulatory Takings

One Distinction Too Many
by  Richard A. Epstein  

At this moment, it looks as though the law of eminent domain takings is in a quiet phase, as the Supreme Court has not recently taken any major case that examines the foundations of the field. One apparently settled area of takings jurisprudence deals with rent control, where the Court provides only scant protection to…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

wedding-rings

Essay

The Ninth Circuit’s Perry Decision and the Constitutional Politics of Marriage Equality

by  William N. Eskridge Jr.  

In Perry v. Brown, the Ninth Circuit ruled that California’s Proposition 8 violates the Equal Protection Clause. Reacting to the state supreme court’s recognition of marriage equality for lesbian and gay couples, Proposition 8 was a 2008 voter initiative that altered the state constitution to “restore” the “traditional” understanding of civil marriage to exclude same-sex…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

Response

The Right to Be Forgotten

by  Jeffrey Rosen  

At the end of January, the European Commissioner for Justice, Fundamental Rights, and Citizenship, Viviane Reding, announced the European Commission’s proposal to create a sweeping new privacy right—the “right to be forgotten.” The right, which has been hotly debated in Europe for the past few years, has finally been codified as part of a broad…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

Response

Famous for Fifteen People

Celebrity, Newsworthiness, and Fraley v. Facebook
by  Simon J. Frankel, Laura Brookover & Stephen Satterfield  

A recent case in the Northern District of California, Fraley v. Facebook,[1] recalls singer-songwriter Momus’s prescient parody of Andy Warhol: “In the future, everyone will be famous for fifteen people.”[2] Although Momus was discussing the revolution in the recording and distribution of music made possible by digital technologies that allowed performers outside the mainstream to…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

Response

Paving the Regulatory Road to the “Learning Health Care System”

by  Deven McGraw  

The poor quality and high cost of health care in the U.S. is well documented. The widespread adoption of electronic medical records—for purposes of improving quality and reducing costs—is key to reversing these trends.[1] But federal privacy regulations do not set clear and consistent rules for access to health information to improve health care quality.…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

Response

Yes We Can (Profile You)

A Brief Primer on Campaigns and Political Data
by  Daniel Kreiss  

caucus living within one hundred miles of the straw poll in Ames, Iowa.[1] In the months leading up to the caucuses Mitt Romney’s presidential campaign purchased ads that ran before all YouTube videos watched by voters in Iowa and New Hampshire.[2]Meanwhile, through sophisticated voter modeling, targeted communications based on voters’ political interests, and tracking the…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

Response

Privacy in the Age of Big Data

A Time for Big Decisions
by  Omer Tene & Jules Polonetsky  

We live in an age of “big data.” Data has become the raw material of production, a new source of immense economic and social value. Advances in data mining and analytics and the massive increase in computing power and data storage capacity have expanded, by orders of magnitude, the scope of information available to businesses,…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

Response

A Reasonableness Approach to Searches After the Jones GPS Tracking Case

by  Peter Swire C. & William O’Neill Professor  

In the oral argument this fall in United States v. Jones,[1] several Supreme Court Justices struggled with the government’s view that it can place Global Positioning System (GPS) tracking devices on cars without a warrant or other Fourth Amendment limit. Chief Justice Roberts asked: “You think there would also not be a search if you…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

abandoned-basketball

Essay

The 2011 Basketball Lockout

The Union Lives to Fight Another Day—Just Barely
by  William B. Gould IV  

Sports in 2011 was synonymous with labor-management relations, which became contentious in two of the three sports in which collective bargaining agreements expired—football and basketball. The National Basketball Association (NBA or the owners), for its part, made it clear that it would utilize a lockout as a means of economic pressure to obtain the kind…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

leaving-iraq

Essay

The Iraq War, the Next War, and the Future of the Fat Man

by  Stephen L. Carter  

When the last American combat troops departed Iraq in December, they left behind a disordered democracy that may not survive, along with a great deal of ethical confusion. The invasion of Iraq in 2003 represented the apotheosis of “anticipatory” self-defense—the theory that the use of armed force can be justified to prevent an attack that…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

health-care-cases

Essay

How to Reach the Constitutional Question in the Health Care Cases

by  Daniel J. Hemel  

Although the Supreme Court has agreed to hear three suits challenging the 2010 health care reform legislation, it is not at all clear that the Court will resolve the constitutional questions at stake in those cases. Rather, the Justices may decide that a Reconstruction-era statute, the Tax Anti-Injunction Act (TA-IA), requires them to defer a…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

at-sign-seized

Essay

Don’t Break the Internet

by  Mark Lemley, David S. Levine & David G. Post  

Two bills now pending in Congress—the PROTECT IP Act of 2011 (Protect IP) in the Senate and the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) in the House—represent the latest legislative attempts to address a serious global problem: large-scale online copyright and trademark infringement. Although the bills differ in certain respects, they share an underlying approach and…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

drones-eye-view

Essay

The Drone as Privacy Catalyst

by  M. Ryan Calo  

Associated today with the theatre of war, the widespread domestic use of drones for surveillance seems inevitable. Existing privacy law will not stand in its way. It may be tempting to conclude on this basis that drones will further erode our individual and collective privacy. Yet the opposite may happen. Drones may help restore our…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

statue-of-liberty-sunset

Essay

Sweet Home Alabama?

Immigration and Civil Rights in the “New” South
by  Kevin R. Johnson  

In the next few weeks, the Supreme Court will decide whether to review the constitutionality of Arizona’s high-profile immigration enforcement effort, known popularly as S.B. 1070. Arizona’s law is simply the tip of the iceberg. State legislatures have passed immigration enforcement laws over the last few years at breakneck speed, and, generally speaking, have attempted…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

crashing-stock

Essay

Misconceptions About Lehman Brothers’ Bankruptcy and the Role Derivatives Played

by  Kimberly Summe  

On November 4, 2011, Lehman Brothers’ creditors voted on Lehman Brothers’ liquidation plan, with approval from the bankruptcy court to follow on December 6, 2011. In the three years since the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, which was the largest bankruptcy filing in U.S. history, Congress enacted the Dodd-Frank Act to prevent the failure of another…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

arab-spring_0

Essay

Constitutions as Peace Treaties

A Cautionary Tale for the Arab Spring
by  Allen S. Weiner  

The December 2010 self-immolation of 26-year-old Tunisian Mohamed Bouazizi, a desperate response to the debilitating lack of economic opportunities for Tunisia’s youth and the pervasive sense of humiliation engendered by the state’s corrupt and degrading treatment of its citizens, tapped into deep popular frustration in Tunisia and throughout the Middle East. It sparked a series…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)

holding-prison-bars

Essay

California’s De Facto Sentencing Commissions

by  Robert Weisberg  

The concept of a sentencing commission as a mechanism for governance of a jurisdiction’s criminal justice system has achieved great prominence in recent years and been the subject of much important commentary. In light of California’s recent passage of A.B. 109, legislation that drastically overhauls the state’s sentencing and correctional systems, now is an ideal…

Volume 64 (2011-2012)