To maintain the integrity of the blind evaluation process for student submissions, please address any comments and questions to Tierney O’Rourke, Executive Editor for Volume 69, at firstname.lastname@example.org. Your questions will then be passed along to Maria Buxton, Senior Notes Editor for Volume 69, with any identifying information removed.
What is a Note or Comment?
- A Note is a student-authored piece of academic writing which discusses and analyzes an original legal issue or problem in some depth.
- A Comment is a student-authored piece of academic writing that is centered around an analysis or critique of a recent case, piece of legislation, law journal article, or law-related book. Comments are also significantly shorter than Notes.
Who can submit?
The Notes Committee encourages all Stanford Law School students to submit their written work for publication. If you are not a Stanford student you must submit your work as an Article. We strongly encourage all students interested in submitting to download the Guide to Student Submissions, which provides critical information about the Notes/Comments process, including guidelines for making a submission, details about the selection process, and information about what makes a good student submission.
All identifying information, including the author’s name and any acknowledgements, must be removed prior to submission. Further, authors should take care not to discuss their work with any members of the Notes Committee.
- Notes cannot be longer than 17,500 words.
- Comments cannot be longer than 7,500 words.
These word limits include footnotes (be careful, as the default setting in Microsoft Word does not include footnotes in the word count), but do not include the table of contents, the Statement of Originality, or the Statement of Resubmission.
Limit on Submissions
During each Note/Comment call, a student may make no more than two total submissions (including both Comments and Notes).
Statement of Originality
All Notes and Comments must contain a Statement of Originality detailing how the argument being advanced fits into the current literature. It should be clear from this Statement how your argument differs from those of other authors. For Comments, please include a list of other reviews on the case, legislation, article, or book, and address how yours adds to them. The Statement should also provide information about the published scholarship that underlies or inspired the piece, the names of professors who would be well-suited to review the submission (they need not be at Stanford), and the names of professors who are already familiar with the piece and its authorship. The Statement of Originality should be inserted at the front of the submission, as a cover page.
Statement of Resubmission
All resubmitted work must contain a Statement of Resubmission detailing how the paper has been improved since the prior submission. The author should include in this Statement a discussion of how she has taken into consideration any feedback provided by the Notes Committee from the prior submission.